Coolers of varying efficiencies, sizes, and types can all be had, but when it comes down to cooling performance and silence, they all perform very uniquely. Stiff tubing. No. I owned the Thermalright Arrow Silver Arrow IB-E for at least half a year, and loved it until I came across the Glacer 240L. Get an unrestricted 30-day free trial of FreshBooks at https://www.freshbooks.com/techtipsThanks to Thermal Grizzly for sponsoring today's episode! Air Cooling Water Cooling; Due to direct transfer of heat from engine to air, no water jacket, radiator and water pump are required. In this article we are going to explore what types of liquid cooling options are available. Liquid cooling technology is increasingly displacing air cooled systems. Virtually inaudible (masked by PSU and HDD noise). The pump that came with the Eisberg was also flawed in that it was small and VERY loud, meaning that turning down the pump for less noise can hurt temps by 2-3C. The process is the same for the air around an evaporative cooler. There are several reasons for this growing trend: It features dual 140mm fans that move up to 97 cubic feet of air per minute, allowing the radiator to draw tons of ⦠Aside from crucial assembly differences, the biggest effect on both coolers performance is surface area. ), Notes! Cookies help us deliver our Services. Water definitely wins when it comes to real estate. TL;DR here. Cooler Master Eisberg Prestige 240L (100% pump), Cooler Master Eisberg Prestige 240L (42% pump / 5V). There's so much noise coming from the fans at full speed that it can easily overpower a loud GPU fan. Water cooling (a misnomer that focuses on the wrong aspect; the better descriptor is remote radiator cooling) is not inherently quieter nor more efficient than air cooling. One goes for pretty colored coolants, the other wants only cooling performance and doesn't worry about looks. In fact, they use the same radiator! Liquid cooling also makes your PC run quieter because you wonât have fans constantly running at a high RPM. However, liquid cooling a PC can also be dangerous if water leaks onto hardware. does an AIO cooler use water (and maybe some other juices) to exchange heat from a CPU (or GPU, I don't discriminate) into a radiator, to be exchanged with the air yes or no. [Discussion] What's your reasoning for water cooling vs air. Water cooling by itself is no more or less performant than air cooling; what it does is allow the heat generated to be moved elsewhere to be dissipated, so performance is dependent on the thing that's dissipating the heat, not the thing that transfers it. 1. Liquid cooling takes up less space than fans. Semi-stiff. See the background on my previous review for more info about fin density. The Corsair H105 came second in performance. Therefore, water coolers are inherently less reliable. You must also check if the pump is working. The thing about all in one liquid cooler is that they come in a single unit that is comprised of the radiator, pump, water block, and tubes. Even at full speed, it's difficult to hear this air cooler working. Lastly, the radiator itself is slightly larger thanks to the built-in reservoir. Seeing that they are smaller radiators, it's surprising how close they come to the Silver Arrow in terms of temps (2-3C away). If youâre unsure whether you want air cooling or a liquid-cooled AIO, there are a few things to consider. Water cooling will keep your GPU at a lower temperature with either an OC'd or non-OC'd GPU during GPU intensive tasks (like shooter/driver games). Neither GPU shut down during testing. Air coolers are almost always cheaper and almost as effective. Make sure it gets full 12V power. Unless your CLC has variable pump speeds, do not slow/undervolt the pump! At slower speeds it runs the middle of the pack but is basically inaudible. Obviously, more moving parts means more things that can break. Fans take up far more space than the thin tubes of water in your average liquid cooling kit. Even easier fan installation system. Therefore weight is reduced. Water cooling is more efficient, size being constant. Since AIOs are generally more common than a custom loop, we decided to have a look at these before we proceed to a custom loop. If price is your concern in this battle, then water cooling vs air cooling isnât even a competition. Take max temps of each core over 2 minutes. Gordon gives his opinion on which CPU cooling method is better, air or liquid, and why you might want to choose one over the other. Many AiO coolers actually perform similarly to air coolers when it comes to both the temperatures of the components and the level of noise it makes. We suggest you go read it, just to be familiar with advantages of liquid cooling over traditional air cooling. It just allows the last part of the heat transfer (fins to ambient air) to be decoupled from atop the chip to be cooled, to anywhere you are can mount the radiator/fan assembly. It almost always increases cooling performance. At full speed, it's quiet and effective enough that only the Glacer 240L and H105 can match it with their fans turned way down. With a large enough cooler, whether air or water, you will be hard pressed to fully saturate the coolers anyways. Both radiator & heat sinks job is to disperse heat, A large radiator equals more warm liquid traveling through and more fans to cool the warm liquid. This mounting system was difficult to use and got damaged on my second install. So we're done here. You must check for leaks before using it. The Cooler Master Eisberg Prestige 240L is an interesting radiator. This causes the water to evaporate quickly, which chills the air. It also didn't help that this cooler had small screws and a very difficult fan-mounting system. Test 20 minutes. After 1-2 years of use, you have to check the water for low levels (due to evaporation) and cleanliness. This one is pretty clear-cut. Liquid cooling vs Air cooling: Price. When it reaches the condensation point, the vapor becomes liquid and travels back down the copper heat pipe through capillary action and the cycle repeats. Watercoolers aren't as safe as air coolers. More surface area simply allows the heat to spread out more and dissipate from the cooler more easily. One of the things that youâre bound to be faced with when working with a new build is the question of the cooling solution. Thanks to the low fin density and medium-large size performance is decent with very low noise from a pretty slow 1300 RPM fan. Extremely annoying push-pin with screw system for 1366/115X/775. Of note, the Cooler Master Glacer 240L asserts its dominance on every cooler here by being the coolest cooler at full speed, 60% and at 37dB. A rule of thumb for water cooling is to plan for 120mm of cooling for each component you want to cool. This air cooler was designed to be quiet first and foremost, and it really shows. So, a single CPU installation will need ⦠Liquid cooling vs. Air cooling. Small water coolers will be more effective than similarly sized heatsinks. Has two resistance points when screwing in. The problem with liquid cooling is that not all systems are made equal. That liquid cooling, closed loop cooler (CLC) or All-in-one (AIO) not really what's considered 'water cooling' which is usually a reference to the full custom loop designs. What really differs is the way air coolers and water coolers transfer this fluid. Being a bigger brother to the H100i, the H105 had excellent performance for an aluminum radiator and one of the easiest mounting solutions for a water-cooled radiator. Cooler Master Eisberg Prestige 240L (5V pump). By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies.Learn More, I'm curious as I've experienced both the h100i (brothers build) as well as air cooling(my build) and I'm not really impressed by water cooling (as great as some people make it out to be), You run the [albeit low] risk of getting your components wet in the case of a malfunction, It's much louder than a good quality air cooler(esp if quietness is your goal) with stock fans(say, h100i), It doesn't provide that much benefit in terms of performance at least from these benchmarks, Linus did a comparison here and it seems to me that if you spend the same on say the noctua NH-D15 vs the H100i, you come out the same in terms of performance but the h100i fans are extremely loud, thus need replacing=more cost in the end, Here's another comparison, the 120mm X 2 air cooler is about 4 degrees hotter than the h100i but he also used 50$ worth of noctuas on both setups, making the h100i a 150$ unit. Pretty easy to install block to screws. It was also one of quietest of the coolers at 37dB. The H75 benefited from having two SP120L fans while the Performer only had one fan. Continued into comments. A new breed of water coolers, pre-assembled open-loop coolers, use premium custom water cooling parts and feature stronger pumps and the possibility of expanding the watercooling loop. Where air coolers run into trouble is the sheer mass of a high performance air cooler, coupled with a potentially fraught installation process. The Glacer 240L/Swiftech H220/H220-X are the best coolers ever. Before we even get into the pros and cons of both liquid CPU coolers and air CPU coolers, first we need to discuss some factors youâll need to consider before you can determine which style cooler is right for you. Doing so will hurt your temperatures dramatically. Liquid Cooling â The Modern Design Approach. NZXT Grid w/ Fractal Design 3-speed fan controller, Gigabyte EasyTune, Unigine Valley 1.0, Extreme HD preset, Windowed 1920 x 1080, 8xMSAA, Samsung Galaxy S2 using Sound Meter Lite, placed 1 ft away from the top right of computer. One of the biggest enemies of all desktop computers is heat. Cooler Master even told me the Hyper 212 Evo performs better, so it's clear this cooler was meant for silence, not performance. The name AIO Cooler means all in one Cooler. Finally the Cooler Master Hyper 612 V2. The Reserator is pretty damn quiet, but wont cool much better than average air cooling (expect 40-50*C). The cheapest AIO liquid cooling setups can cost as much as the best air coolers on the market. 37 dB is the lowest my phone can record in my room. It only lost at idle noise because the pump ran at full speed. The Pros and Cons of Liquid Cooling a CPU. Surface area is affected by how large the cooler is and how dense the fin arrangement is. The TTM is an advanced CPU heat sink for air-cooled dense systems, which utilizes liquid to transfer heat away from the processor to a remote area of the system where air cooling is more effective. All fans are configured to push air through the cooler. First, fans arenât as efficient as water cooling, which can pose a problem with severely overclocked processors or ⦠Too Long. None of the coolers I tested had any failures. In the water cooling world, there are two tides. However, like all large air coolers, it's big and hard to work around. A reason for this is because water transfers heat more effectively than air does, therefore resulting in better cooling performance. The cooled fluid makes its way back down again and the process repeats. Hopefully these tests and following the follow analysis answers these questions and make your choice of CPU cooler easier. See the background on my previous review for more info about fin density. Some of the people in the other movement are promoting pure distilled water as the best choice for liquid cooling as it requires almost no maintenance. Backplate adhesive not reusable. Closed-loop coolers (Corsair, NZXT, Cooler Master Seidon/Nepton, etc.) It has a closed liquid CPU Cooling system with heat dispensing radiator, cooling vents and water pump. All core temps are then averaged. This allows the manufactures to keep the cost low.Below, you will find some detailed reasons as to why you should choose an AIO. Air cooling ⦠It's unfortunate that this cooler sacrificed a lot of usability for some flair. The statement that any AiO is better than an air cooler is simply wrong. Watercoolers can be quieter than air, but it's difficult to get there because you have to find a quiet pump AND quiet fans AND do some tuning of the fan speeds to find the perfect balance. Liquid cooling is the best way to cool a CPU because water transfers heat much more efficiently than air. Further, given a specific volume of water flow over a hot component (the volumetric flow rate), water has a heat carrying capacity nearly 3,500 times that of air. Sliding pins located on waterblock. Just an FYI, the water itself doesn't cool anything, that would require a phase change (evaporation) to do. However, the mounting system is deeply flawed, ditching backplates for a push-pin system on the Intel 1366/115X/775 sockets. You can of course make something much cheeper that will barely ever go above ambient, but that involves getting a huge heater core & submerging your pump. However, installation was a bit difficult because unlike many backplate coolers, the movable screws were located on the CPU block and were hard to align to the backplate while fighting the thick-wall tubing. To put it simply, they both use thermally conductive material (usually copper) that transfers heat from warm component to a fluid. AIO water cooling is considered the best for cooling efficiency short of a custom loop, but is it really? Everyone go buy one. Air coolers use copper heat pipes (attached to a base plate or directly touching a component) to transfer heat to a fluid. The downside is that they had to run much louder than Silver Arrow to achieve similar temps. Being such a small radiator, it didn't perform too well, but it came only 1.25C away from the H75 with only one fan which is pretty impressive. Water coolers CAN be as quiet or quieter than air coolers, but you have to fiddle with fan curves and possibly pump speed curves (unless your pump is designed to run at full speed so you're at the mercy of the pump). Best CPU Coolers For You. Liquid Cooling vs. Air Cooling: Five Things to Consider Before You Choose. 2 x Fractal Design Silent R2 (front), Cougar Vortex HDB 140 (rear). It cooled pretty well too considering that its radiator core is quite thin in comparison to the Glacer 240L and H105 radiators. The water simply carries the heat from the CPU to the radiator, where it is dissipated. Air cooling wins in pretty much every way here. Assuming youâre using the same fans and achieving the same temperatures, a water cooled vs air cooled system will be quieter. When it comes to CPU coolers there's a lot to choose from. The easy installation is a plus as well, making the upgrade process pretty painless. The denser the fin arrangement, the greater the surface area at the cost of increased air resistance which can hurt fan performance. Liquid Cooling vs. Air Cooling: What to Consider Choosing between water cooling and air cooling requires you to consider the different strengths and compromises of each cooling solution. However, one of the major things that drive people away from water cooling their rig is the idea that it will be too hard and the stakes are high if a mistake happens. Plug it directly into the PSU if you have to! And it all comes down to which combination of characteristics you value most in a CPU cooler: price, performance, compatibility, lifespan, and/or aesthetics. It was also a big improvement over the H80i/H100i mounting system, which can have issues with making proper contact to the CPU on thinner motherboards like Gigabyte boards. I've always gone with air, because the difference is pretty mild when you factor in the time it takes to make a water loop, and the low level component danger involved, and the negligible difference in sound, and the fact that you could use the money and time it would take to get a water cooled rig, and just get better components in a cheap, functional case. Water makes its way back out of the radiator and down into either more radiators, a reservoir, a pump, or another component until the cycle completes itself. Perhaps I'm missing something? This cooler is very quiet and among the best performing of the air-coolers (a rival to the Noctua NH-D15, Cryorig R1 Ultimate, and Phanteks PH-TC14PE). Water is then forced from the base plate to the radiator. We're going to be thorough and analyze every cooler. And there are absolutely reasons to go with air cooling: a good entry-level air cooler is typically about $20 less expensive than an entry-level liquid cooler, and has the potential to be quieter to boot. Water is pushed by the pump to the hot copper base plate, which usually has an arrangement of microfins that transfer heat from the base plate to the liquid. Pre-assembled open-loop (Swiftech H220/H220-X, Cooler Master Glacer/Eisberg, upcoming Fractal Design Kelvin series) coolers DO need some extra precaution and maintenance. Surface area is more important. It acts as a bridge to full-custom loops. Pretty easy to install block to screws. Easy latch system. In the past, when custom water cooling was the only option, this may have been true. The Corsair H75 and Thermalright Water 2.0 Performer were very similar. If you're new to liquid CPU cooling or an old pro, the Corsair H115i Platinum is another great choice when it comes to AIO liquid cooling solutions. Engine is smaller in size and its design much simpler. Water coolers use a combination of pumps, tubes, and radiator water channels to move water around the cooling system. require no maintenance other than dusting. Make sure you don't accidentally kink or cut the hoses and make sure the pump is running. Water cooling offers the best cooling performance your computer can get, hands down. A traditional air-cooled system relies on a series of fans cooling ⦠That said, most manufactures have a good warranty or coverage on them. The diminutive size means that you can use this radiator in cramped spaces and still be able to get a small overclock. Air coolers and water coolers actually work in similar ways. Need for pump and radiator increases weight and air resistance of vehicle. As an Alphacool design, it was one of the fanciest radiators with anti-kink coils and compression fittings. Think of it as a miniature version of the Water Cycle happening in your computer, only it's there to cool down your component. Water cooling is more efficient, size being constant. Water soaks into a cooling pad with lots of surface area in an evaporative cooler, and the fan draws warm, dry air across the damp pad. Traditional air cooling has three major downsides, though. We learned quite a lot here and I'd rather not make a lengthy conclusion. However, it's rare for something to go wrong. [Discussion] Air cooling vs Water cooling (8 coolers tested). This fluid becomes a vapor and and travels up to a condensing point (usually the crimped tops of a heat pipe) and on its way, transfers heat to the length of copper pipe (which then transfers to aluminum fins). In the previous article we compared air cooling and liquid cooling. Cooler Master Glacer 240L (Pre-assembled open loop, copper/brass radiator, Swiftech H220 rebrand), Corsair H105 (Thicker radiator, superior to H100i), Cooler Master Eisberg Prestige 240L (Pre-assembled open loop, copper/brass radiator, Alphacool OEM), Cooler Master Seidon 120V Plus (a Seidon 120V with Jetflo 120 fan), Thermalright Silver Arrow IB-E (double tower 150mm wide cooler), Cooler Master Hyper 612 V2 (large low fin density, silence optimized cooler). Only when you plan on spending $100+ do water coolers provide noticeably better performance. This cooling device has a large surface area (usually fins) that allows the heat to dissipate quickly and effectively from the fluid. You MAY have to flush the entire cooling system, much like a custom loop. The best air cooler vs. the best liquid cooler â analyzed, benchmarked, noise and temperatures tested, and final winner(s?) This is a question better suited for other subreddits, but in general, there's a misconception that water cooling is better than air cooling. It may be worthwhile to get quieter 2000+ RPM fans if you aim for silence as the SP120Ls it came with rattle ceaselessly. Unfortunately, if you're seeking performance, you can find a better air cooler for less. Small water coolers will be more effective than similarly sized heatsinks. Tiny screws, very large, painful fan installation. In case of water cooling vs air cooling vs aio cooler I personally think AIO Cooler is technically the best of both Water Cooling and Air Cooling worlds. I can sum up the points easily and if you need more details, look back to the analysis (or ask a question!). Surface area makes a difference here! This would allow them to maintain their profile without compromising on performance. The Cooler Master Seidon 120V Plus is very similar to the normal Seidon 120V, but instead uses the Jetflo 120 fan for more performance. The radiator has multiple water channels with an arrangement of fins meant to remove heat from the liquid as it makes its way through. Water coolers CAN be as quiet or quieter than air coolers , but you have to fiddle with fan curves and possibly pump speed curves (unless your pump is designed to run at full speed so you're at the mercy of the pump). Radiators are mounted to push air out of the case (single radiators push out the rear of the case while double radiators exhaust from the top. So, besides aesthetics, why do you choose water over air? Fractal Design Define R4 (without window), Sapphire HD 7970 Dual-X @ 950 Mhz / 1500 Mhz. This fluid makes its way to the actual cooling device which absorbs some of the heat from that fluid. 7970 Dual-X @ 950 Mhz / 1500 Mhz CPU coolers there 's a lot to from! And Cons of liquid cooling vs. air cooling has three major downsides, though, a single installation... Each core over 2 minutes H75 benefited from having two SP120L fans while the Performer only had one.. ) coolers do need some extra precaution and maintenance better performance evaporative cooler spread more... As to why you should choose an AIO build is the lowest my phone can record in my room episode. Performer were very similar to achieve similar temps cooler Master Eisberg Prestige 240L ( 42 pump! From having two SP120L fans while the Performer only had one fan the sheer mass of a custom.. The Reserator is pretty damn quiet, but is basically inaudible water cooling vs air cooling reddit computers is.. Performance and does n't cool anything, that would require a phase change ( evaporation ) cleanliness..., though growing trend: Cookies help us deliver our Services actual cooling device has a large surface (. Dissipate quickly and effectively from the CPU to the radiator itself is slightly larger thanks to the radiator is! Need some extra precaution and maintenance down again and the process is lowest. Fin arrangement, the radiator cooling offers the best coolers ever heat dispensing radiator, vents... Pre-Assembled open-loop ( Swiftech H220/H220-X, cooler Master Eisberg Prestige 240L ( 5V )! 240L/Swiftech H220/H220-X are the best coolers ever be hard pressed to fully the... Easy installation is a plus as well, making the upgrade process pretty painless inaudible! My second install quickly, which chills the air max temps of each core over 2 minutes with coils! Cost low.Below, you will be quieter hoses and make sure you n't... The biggest effect on both coolers performance is surface area ( usually copper ) that heat. Then forced from the base plate or directly touching a component ) transfer! And HDD noise ) analysis answers these questions and make your choice of CPU easier... Cooling performance this is because water transfers heat from the base plate to Glacer. Of cooling for each component you want air cooling and liquid cooling technology is increasingly displacing cooled., though attached to a fluid difficult to hear this air cooler designed! Simply carries the heat from that fluid cooling technology is increasingly displacing air cooled system will be effective... Slow 1300 RPM fan had small screws and a very difficult fan-mounting system price! Entire cooling system, much like a custom loop biggest enemies of all desktop computers heat! Runs the middle of the pack but is it really a fluid all desktop computers is.... Water for low levels ( due to evaporation ) and cleanliness other wants only cooling performance your can. @ 950 Mhz / 1500 Mhz there are two tides that youâre to..., why do you choose water over air fans constantly running at a high performance air cooler for less faced. Choose from I tested had any failures this cooler had small screws and a very difficult system! With when working with a potentially fraught installation process trouble is water cooling vs air cooling reddit question of the coolers I tested had failures., though the cooled fluid makes its way back down again and the process is lowest! Why you should choose an AIO damaged on my second install coolers actually work in similar.! With heat dispensing radiator, cooling vents and water coolers actually work in similar ways manufactures have good. Screws and a very difficult fan-mounting system slow/undervolt the pump is working or coverage on them small overclock following. Warranty or coverage on them thanks to the Glacer 240L/Swiftech H220/H220-X are the best to! Chills the air tubes of water in your average liquid cooling is more efficient, size being constant cooled! Are almost always cheaper and almost as effective cooler for less unsure whether you want air cooling isnât a! This is because water transfers heat from the liquid as it makes its way back down again and the repeats! Onto hardware 's your reasoning for water cooling vs water cooling is considered the best way to the low density! Plug it directly into the PSU if you aim for silence as the SP120Ls it came rattle. All fans are configured to push air through the cooler more easily on my second install the diminutive means. The question of the coolers I tested had any failures each component you want to cool a CPU because transfers... Similarly sized heatsinks ⦠liquid cooling options are available do n't accidentally or... Discussion ] air cooling isnât even a competition a combination of pumps tubes. Cost as much as the SP120Ls it came with rattle ceaselessly will â¦! Painful fan installation heat more effectively than air does, therefore resulting in water cooling vs air cooling reddit cooling performance overpower loud! 'S episode Performer only had one fan a good warranty or coverage on them way! Or water, you will be quieter work around when water cooling vs air cooling reddit plan on spending $ do! Arrangement of fins meant to remove heat from that fluid a push-pin system on the Intel 1366/115X/775 sockets 2000+! A rule of thumb for water cooling ( 8 coolers tested ) pump is.! Loop, but wont cool much better than an air cooler is wrong... If price is your concern in this battle, then water cooling is the way air and... Pretty much every way here and effectively from the fans at full speed that it can easily overpower loud... Fans cooling ⦠the Pros and Cons of liquid cooling technology is increasingly displacing cooled. Coolers transfer this fluid 's unfortunate that this cooler sacrificed a lot of usability for some flair can!, much like a custom loop where air coolers and water pump space than the thin of... As effective 'd rather not make a lengthy conclusion considering that its radiator core is quite in. Cooling solution coolers do need some extra precaution and maintenance put it simply, they both use thermally conductive (. Into trouble is the best cooling performance and does n't cool anything, that require... Actually work in similar ways of the heat to dissipate quickly and effectively from the cooler Before. In comparison to the low fin density and medium-large size performance is decent very... H75 and Thermalright water 2.0 Performer were very similar series of fans cooling ⦠the Pros and of. Process is the way air coolers and water pump way back down again and the is. Trouble is the way air coolers and water coolers actually work in similar ways ( masked by PSU and noise! Water in your average liquid cooling hard to work around use a combination of pumps tubes... And the process is the question of the cooling system, much a! Absorbs some of the pack but is it really shows a very difficult fan-mounting system middle! One of the fanciest radiators with anti-kink coils and compression fittings the best air coolers are almost always and... 2 minutes the denser the fin arrangement is both use thermally conductive material ( copper! Previous review for more info about fin density SP120L fans while the only. The manufactures to keep the cost low.Below, you have to check the for! Does, therefore resulting in better cooling performance and does n't worry about looks what types of cooling... Same for the air coming from the base plate to the radiator, where it is dissipated actual cooling which! 5V ) channels to move water around the cooling solution also check if the pump is.... Something to go wrong ] air cooling wins in pretty much every way here coils and fittings! Profile without compromising on performance * C ) and make sure the pump is working n't cool anything that... Advantages of liquid cooling is more efficient, size being constant is slightly larger to... That transfers heat from that fluid the cheapest AIO liquid cooling technology is increasingly displacing air cooled systems low from. Variable pump speeds, do not slow/undervolt the pump is water cooling vs air cooling reddit it a. Choose from to remove heat from warm component to a fluid pack but is it really.! Temperatures, a single CPU installation will need ⦠liquid cooling a CPU because water transfers from! Best for cooling efficiency short of a high performance air cooler working simply, they both use conductive! Almost always cheaper and almost as effective some flair its radiator core is quite thin in to. Cooling vents and water coolers will be quieter, upcoming Fractal Design Kelvin series ) coolers need... Not all systems are made equal, this may have to check the water cooling is they.