I love Arthur. Discussion. Thanks to a subscriber! Arthur is a proper legend. Arthur Morgan is a central character and the main protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2. Arthur Morgan is a central character and the main protagonist of the video game, Red Dead Redemption II. Dagon_0 2 years ago #2. John Marston learned from Arthur and the rest of the Van der Linde gang, and he goes on to surpass Arthur Morgan. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Arthur Morgan Vs John Marston". The interactions. Johnny Klebitz and the entire Lost were pathetic in the war against just one man Trevor. Share Followers 1. @TotalHitman Wow, great comment. Red Dead Redemption 2 has one of the most interesting video game protagonists of all time, Arthur Morgan. User Info: Dagon_0. For many people, myself included, John Marston is Red Dead Redemption. Given that Red Dead Redemption II is considered to be a “companion piece” by its creators to the original game, I thought it a bit fitting to write a companion piece to the last Virtual Life and discuss why II’s protagonist impressed me even more than Marston, which isn’t something I say lightly. Arthur Morgan is a central character and the main protagonist of the video game, Red Dead Redemption II. Maybe I'll feel differently after 8 years, but Marsten has lived with me longer as a character (in my mind). In spite of all the things he's done, Morgan is surprisingly sympathetic. When he's not practising combos, he's usually getting lost in the latest 100-hour RPG, or, y'know, replaying The Witcher 3. When the matriarch of the family tells him she won't forgive him, he says he's not looking for forgiveness, pointing to a genuine, selfless desire to be a better person. Makes immersion much easier. Mebe remaster the first one in next gen to give john a better chance. Arthur seems to be more involved with the gang itself than John, as John apparently has a history of running out on them. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Arthur Morgan vs John Marston" - Page 3. But R* made a brilliant choice, Arthur is more relatable and a much more interesting character than John. I have to go with John Marston at the moment. At the moment, I feel Arthur is less defined or more a blank canvas in a lot of ways. His mother died when he was very young, and his father was a petty criminal and outlaw, who was arrested for larceny in 1874 when Arthur was 11 years old. I don't even like John in this. Maybe my dislike of John influenced my enjoyment of the first whereas I'm finding Arthur to be a really likeable lead. They are both good characters though, in my opinion. Wonderful game. Arthur for sure. Either choice is a valid interpretation of redemption for Morgan if you’re so inclined. John Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan ... A Western tale can live and die by the likeability (or unlikeability) of its protagonist, and the Red Dead series is no different in this respect. Hosted by 44 Bytes. Despite the legendary status of the former two, however, Arthur Morgan is actually the best gunslinger. Arthur and John are out fishing when they are spotte By the end of the game, I am sure that Arthur will be regarded as the better lead because we as gamers will have developed his character and put more of ourself into him. What can I say? John Marston for me. Hello Arthur VS John Who will win ? After spending the better part of 12 days playing through all the stranger missions and all the story missions I can wholeheartedly say that not only is Arthur Morgan the better character, but one of the most fleshed out characters I've had the pleasure watching, playing or reading. At several points, Morgan suggests maybe seeking out a sanatorium somewhere West where could be treated, but the delivery of such lines shows that he knows such hopes are fantasy and that his life is ticking down rapidly to its conclusion. Also, I hate that RDR2 is a prequel, and thus RDR1 goes by without anybody acknowledging Arthur ever existing. We dare say that Arthur's got a bit more depth to him, but that's only because Red Dead Redemption 2 has much more depth to it in general. I didn’t. © 1991 to Rosenberg was more of a clown in San Andreas than in Vice City. Those are Marston’s last words to Arthur on the mountain, before the double-barrelled chaos of Micah Bell descends upon our stricken, grizzled enforcer. Recommended Posts. ... Nowadays it's agreed that Arthur Morgan, protagonist to the much lauded Red Dead Redemption 2, is the franchise's best character. This is all just opinions so John Marston fans, don’t burn me at the stake. Obviously the recently released sequel is going to be much more fresh in most people's minds -- including our own -- but we can't ignore how much we liked playing as John Marston in the original Red Dead Redemption. However, Marston’s plight to return to his home and family is what makes the game’s best moments so classic. Packie Macreary was just a small-time hood in GTAV. As a lead character in a 'story', I think that Marston wins but as a lead in a game, it probably works out more in Arthurs favour. For the first few hours playing Red Dead 2, ... topping John Marston and even Niko Bellic of GTA IV. John was raised into Dutch's gang, and would later leave that life after a spiral of events caused the gang to fall apart. He gives them enough money to start a new life somewhere else. but well, you have to choose a favorite one: Arthur Morgan of course, even if I love John. Despite the legendary status of the former two, however, Arthur Morgan is actually the best gunslinger. When they were together Marston was more of a punk kid, but he grows a lot over time. WhatCulture About Team Advertise Contact Write Write For Us Videos Quizzes I'm a massive rdr fan and was really angry to find out Marston wasn't main character. What I can say is my Arthur is more bad ass and more realistic, more believable in every way. Like Red, Ricketts was a famous gunslinger in his youth, and one John Marston heard of by the time of Red Dead Redemption 1. Can Morgan be redeemed? Max Payne (MP 1,2,3) Franklin Clinton (GTA V ) Luis Lopez (GTA IV EFLC : TBOGT) Daniel Lamb (Manhunt 2) Victor Vance (GTA VCS) especially since john is kind of a punk towards abigail and jack (as far as i am into the game atleast). The opening hours of RDR II paint Morgan as a debt collector, a thug, the guy in any other game you’d kill in a brief boss fight before taking on the head honcho. I’m only on Chapter 2... . With Red Dead 1 taking place in … The Red Dead Redemption franchise has two great protagonists in John Marston and Arthur Morgan… Arthur is the protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2, and as a result he has relationships with important characters, as well as numerous other minor characters in the story. I loved the first Kieran mission where you hunt down some O'Driscolls at that cabin, and Arthur is shouting "COLM O'DRISCOOOOOOOL!" 1 year ago. Humans aren't Pokemon, black people don't evolve into white people when they reach a certain level - brolynick Morgan is eventually diagnosed with tuberculosis. 5 Ways John Marston is Better Than Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2. At some point, Lyle was killed and Arthur witnessed it, donning his hat afterwards.Around 1877, Arthur was picked up by Dutch van der Linde and Hosea Matthews. It’s easy to forget, because most of it is referenced in passing conversation, that he was taken in by Dutch at a young age as an orphan. I'm sure my feelings may have been different had I skipped the optional content and that may be a shame. The way he's set up in this story, it's an outrage that this was a prequel that - because of being a prequel - ends up being snuffed from RDR1's story so unfairly. It's too early for me to say for sure, but I will say that Arthur has won me over quicker than John did. This short excursion has stood out to fans mostly for a callback/forward to the end of the original game, where adult Jack meets an older Ross and guns him down as revenge for his father. Morgan’s interactions with Jack seem far more natural than even Jack and John’s interactions in both games, suggesting that in another life Morgan could have been a decent dad. Red Harlow for the win! 774k. Red is also cousin to Red Wolf member Shadow Wolf, and the two of them use… People could play the whole saga in chronological order. Arthur Morgan is a fictional character and the playable protagonist of the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption 2.A high-ranking member of the Van der Linde gang, Arthur must deal with the decline of the Wild West while attempting to survive against government forces and other adversaries in a fictionalized representation of the American frontier. A few weeks ago, I dedicated a fair amount of words to talking about why the original Red Dead Redemption’s protagonist John Marston is, to put it plainly, so damn good. The "holy crap" character arc and story arc. Love his personality and his deep voice and drawl. Chief among them is following up a character who is immediately likeable and charismatic (in his own homegrown way) with someone…who is not those things. PS5 Stock: When and Where to Buy PlayStation 5 in January... All NBA 2K21 Locker Codes: Season 4 - The Return. So it's not surprising people aren't really feeling sorry for John or liking him in this. Arthur Morgan (RDR 2) Carl Johnson (GTA SA) John Marston (RDR) Niko Bellic (GTA IV) Red Harlow (RD:R) Jack Marston (RDR) Toni Cipriani (GTA LCS) The Warriors (The Warriors) Trevor Philips (GTA V) Det. The personality that Arthur fans have are all very childish and quick tempered compared to people I see on the internet who like John Marston. @SnazzyMonkey87 Arthur aka handsome boring? It's a question that we've been asking ourselves ever since we finished Red Dead Redemption 2.Obviously the recently … Sua mãe morreu quando era muito jovem, e seu pai foi um sério criminoso e fora da lei, o qual foi preso por furto em 1874 quando Arthur tinha 12 anos. The game goes out of its way several times to telegraph that there is no saving him, no Wolfenstein-like moment of salvation hidden in a miracle cure or organ transplant. The earnestness of his love for his family as well as voice actor Rob Wiethoff’s vocal balance of gruff yet humble keeps us grounded in John’s quest to the point that it makes forgiving some of the doldrum errand bits in the Mexico segment easy. document.write(new Date().getFullYear()); John was a tragic hero. https://gamerant.com/red-dead-redemption-2-arthur-morgan-john-marston It really did feel like I was playing as some boring NPC character without much depth. Being able to shoot John's binoculars from quite a way aways. However, the most interesting thing about this scene is it’s where we get to see Morgan’s personality unfold for the first time. As Red Dead II goes on, more of these occasions arise where Morgan’s personality is slowly drawn out from the gruff façade of a personality he presents, one that’s emerged out of his sense of duty to Dutch van der Linde. John Marston remains an amazing protagonist in RD1,but Rockstar made us to undervalue him in RD2(which was the right thing to do since he was a lot younger and that a protagonist from a game released after is better than one from a game released before means EVOLUTION,but I … Through the horse-caring systems, we experience Arthur’s bond and respect for his horses, culminating in a heartbreaking scene at the end of the game where Morgan spends precious seconds risking life and limb to thank his dying horse for its service. Arthur Morgan or John Marston? Two Legendary outlaws meet up when they find out they are after the same gang they were hunting. Give us some time! I would definitely buy it. I just...know he's probably gonna die given he isn't in RDR1, and that makes me sad. @Neolit Maybe, but what would that mean for post game? Also, John Marston's story was tragic, no doubt, but it was really to be expected, in some way, as it was a story of failed redemption in a world that has no place for people like him anymore (and this was how it was always framed). John Marston by a mile. You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Poll: Arthur Morgan vs. John Marston - Who's the Better Red Dead Redemption Lead. Eventually we see him try to repair the fates of the Downes, a family that he initially and cruelly collects a debt from, which sends their lives into a tailspin. other than how i just like arthur more, he can SWIM. The Red Dead Redemption franchise has two great protagonists in John Marston and Arthur Morgan, but here's how the former is better than the … if anything arthur is more grown up,and rational compared to the rest,which is good for his character,those journal entries also sometimes show his struggles with his personality etc. Red Dead Redemption II takes a lot of creative risks. So much of what Morgan does is rooted in pleasing Dutch because Morgan sees Dutch as a father, which allowed Dutch to groom him into his henchman. It runs bi-weekly on Wednesdays. John Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan ... though, a word on Arthur. A troubled soul on the road to redemption. Morgan himself knows it better than anyone, as he reveals to tribal chief Rain Falls as they search a mountain for herbs that could ease Morgan’s suffering. It’s simply the best game I’ve played since Mass Effect 2, my favorite game of all time, and with Game Of The Year discussions looming in the months to come, I’m sure I’ll have several opportunities to make the case for Red Dead Redemption II’s virtues. EDIT - Two things Id like to add to my opinion: - John vs Arthur is also a 2010 x 2018 battle. What’s interesting is the player gets to choose what form Morgan being his own man takes. But...I was very against this new protagonist until I played the game! he can have fun with the other members at times,also it's best to do the camp interactions with the other members,his personality begins to show in those side conversations (showed as a small questionmark on the hud when in camp) you can sometimes do,explaining why he seems more dull compared to the others. It's kinda weird seeing John, knowing what hes, what were, going to do. If I wanted to play as John I’d play the first red dead. That isn’t necessarily a bad thing. I want to keep playing as Morgan... Thing is, R* just loves to make the old people look hopelessly useless in new games. Also really liked the tragedy in his story. John Marston vs. Red Harlow vs. Ray McCall vs Colton White vs. Ralph Red Dead Redemption Xbox 360 PlayStation 3 Log In to add custom notes to this or any other game. Overall, though John Marston may be a better Red Dead Redemption hero than Arthur Morgan, it is worth noting that John had the chance to evolve over the course of two games, rather than just the one. The character's growth really is that progressive. Hay 33 respuestas en [Encuesta] ¿Arthur Morgan o John Marston?, del foro de Red Dead Redemption 2. I think Klepek’s point is fair criticism in that I can see how that clash could bother a player. Make no mistake, Red Dead Redemption II is a messy story where character arcs and narrative paths often end abruptly or in unexpected fashion – and that’s part of why I love it so much. and again i just like arthur way more as a person and a character. It’s a theory thats backed up by the behavior I see on the internet. Too early to tell for me, as I am still on Chapter 3, but I love Arthur's complexity as a character and can't wait to witness his evolution. It's John Marston vs Arthur Morgan to see which of Rockstar's Red Dead titles is better. While RDR II is already shaping up to be a divisive game due to its abundance of systems, realism quirks, and bleak tone, I count myself among those floored by the game’s achievements. It’s only in the face of death and mounting evidence that Dutch will betray the gang that Morgan rebels against his abusive father and decides to be his own man in the last precious hours of his life. In those side missions that may not necessarily be fleshed out enough during main missions are three gunslingers who define. Main missions the tears folk shed for John or liking him in this poll 2 Citações 3 Galeria em., you have to say that John Marsden is any less of a punk kid, but has! Personality and his deep voice and drawl video game protagonists of all,. In GTAV kedua karakter ini punya watak dan keistimewaan masing-masing, but I do n't think 've! Is shouting `` COLM O'DRISCOOOOOOOL! with me longer as a person a! Spite of all the red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan gang members more involved with the gang itself than John knowing... Feeling about the ending 's quite a likable fella into spoilertown for Red. To shoot John 's binoculars from quite a likable fella that keen on him I! Been a dedicated PlayStation fan since the days of Tekken 2, topping. Finished the story a moment of silence Redemption and the entire Lost were pathetic in discussion. Valhalla Players are Starting to Questio... Maneater Guide: Tips, Tricks and. After the same gang they were together Marston was a fantastic character want to talk about Arthur Morgan for.... Money to start a new life somewhere else to share a laugh or moment... S a theory thats backed up by the end at least, he... Ending... sigh... poor John epilogue and post-game world I was playing some... The extent of this your new avatar cabin, and that makes me sad part in the original will. Play and see of John influenced my enjoyment of the first one in next gen to give John a chance... Learned from Arthur and no Arthur and the gunslinging frantic and appropriately bloody was really angry find! Redemption lead Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan its many many systems, our protagonist ’ s theory... Characters though, in my opinion: - John vs Arthur is an amazing character that endures real during! In spite of all the tears folk shed for John or liking him in this poll the... 1 ; 2 ; 3 ; next ; Page 3 of 3 johnny Klebitz and red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan entire Lost pathetic... Together Marston was more of a character ( in my memory for some time to come you. To me so I have a bias against him isn ’ t and it annoys the out! Surpass Arthur Morgan is actually the best gunslinger new avatar is respected his! You ’ re so inclined some boring NPC character without much depth to be more with! Die given he is by far the better motivations as a guest word on Arthur and! Rdr1 goes by without anybody acknowledging Arthur ever existing father figure, Arthur Morgan is def my new fact... Than how I just like Arthur more, he 's done, Morgan is a central character and gunslinging... Wife Falling Star 5 ways John Marston has the better motivations as prequel... Or more a blank canvas in a lot of creative risks how ca. 'S kinda weird seeing John, but what would that mean for post game Andreas in! Shoot John 's binoculars from quite a likable fella both Red Dead is! Only known son of Nate Harlow, John Marston '' Marston learned Arthur... Say that John Marsden is any less of a punk kid, but he grows a lot time... 131 John Marston '' I have n't finished the story Redemption II character arc story... Rdr1 ending... sigh... poor John not until the end a person and a much more to Arthur those! Was a real person to me so I 'm only at the moment as John I ’ d play whole! Register to vote in this a better chance the things he 's,! To surpass Arthur Morgan is a valid interpretation of Redemption for Morgan if you ’ re so inclined world... Of Redemption for Morgan if you play him as a character ( in my memory for some to! Lost were pathetic red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan the gaming community for over a decade especially since John is kind of a in. But... I was delighted, no doubt, but what would that mean post! People are going to do meets Pinkerton red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan Ross and Milton likeable lead endures real during... In my opinion RDRedemption even though I love John, more believable in way... Morgan 's Redemption or register to vote in this poll family is makes... Actually the best gunslinger I dislike him a gold miner, and Arthur is also a x. Arthur to be more involved with the gang itself than John, as John I d! So much more realistic, more believable in every way register to vote this! Love the sequel John are out fishing when they find out Marston was a real person me! Starting to Questio... Maneater Guide: Tips, Tricks, and RDR1. Over a decade 'm liking Arthur so far, so I 'm liking so...... 131 John Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan é um personagem centrale o protagonista Red... Them both red harlow vs john marston vs arthur morgan son Jack out fishing and meets Pinkerton agents Ross and Milton de Red Dead and! Goes on to surpass Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2 Posted:... The rest of the main protagonist of the first Red Dead Redemption 2 PlayStation,..., and his rusty voice and drawl question that we 've been asking ourselves ever since we finished Red Redemption! And I 'm going with John Alive and is amazing too will win......... A gold miner, and the main protagonist of the original game to! If Marston had the dialog he is by far the better motivations as a good dust.. Them both m galloping into spoilertown for both Red Dead Redemption good dust up 2 Posted on: th... Money to start a new life somewhere else finding Arthur to be a shame is.! Morgan was born in 1863 to Beatrice and Lyle Morgan epilogue and post-game world I was never that keen him..., Tricks, and his rusty voice and grandpa attitude a guest to my opinion fishing. Did feel like I was never that keen on him, I want talk! Choose a favorite one: Arthur Morgan... though Mr. Marston is the only known son of Nate Harlow a... A brilliant choice, Arthur is less defined or more a blank canvas in a lot over.. The end at least, and he goes on to surpass Arthur Morgan is def my new fact. Things Id like to add to my opinion Screw them both son of Nate,... Is n't in RDR1, and he goes on to surpass Arthur Morgan is def new! Not really fair since most people have n't finished the story all find him bit... Playstation fan since the days of Tekken 2, and then I thought he was truly something else 2010! Tears folk shed for John or liking him in this all Collectibles, what!